Conservatives said "Brokeback Mountain" would bomb in cowboy country. But in red-state Montana, gay cowboys are a big draw. Plus: Christians against Britney! Oprah duped Talese?
Feb. 2, 2006 | For months now, a chorus of televised talking heads has been predicting that the vast majority of Americans wouldn't stand -- let alone stand in line -- for "Brokeback Mountain." Bill O'Reilly, who memorably promised that red-staters would stay home, predicted, "They're not going to go see the gay cowboys in Montana. I'm sorry. They're not going to do it."
But "Brokeback Mountain" isn't just playing in red states like Montana; it has been doing quite well, even before it became the Oscar front-runner this week.
In Missoula, Mont., a town of just under 60,000, the film has been a big hit since it opened at the cavernous Wilma Theater on Jan. 6, grossing $33,006, cumulatively, in its first four weekends there. A representative for Focus Features calls the movie's performance in Missoula "amazing." And Bill Emerson, who manages the 85-year-old theater, confirms that "Brokeback's" draw has been "one of our best starts for a movie we've ever had."
Of course, Missoula is a college town that has long served as a haven for Montana's liberals, hippies and artists. But "Brokeback" isn't doing well only in Missoula. In Kalispell, a stronghold of conservatism in the northwest part of the state, the film opened last Friday and took in $3,656 at the box office its first weekend, a draw Focus says it's "very happy" with. In the equally conservative ski town of Whitefish, where the film also opened on Friday, it was the weekend's top draw, taking in $2,312 and beating out "Big Momma's House 2," "Nanny McPhee" and "Underworld," the top three national box-office draws. And a rep for the company calls the film's performance in Billings, a traditional community in central Montana, where it has taken in $26,065 since opening on Jan. 13, "absolutely phenomenal." "Brokeback" is also doing well in Great Falls and Bozeman, and last weekend opened at No. 1 in Helena.
"I don't know where [the pundits] got the idea that we wouldn't want to see this movie," said Donna Frief, a 59-year-old school secretary from Lolo, Mont., who went to see "Brokeback" in Missoula last week with her daughter and granddaughter. Frief said she "could have done without" some of the more explicit love scenes, but added, "I thought it was just a really beautiful love story. And so sad. It really helped me understand more about the feelings that [gay people] go through."
Judging from the outcomes of the two most recent presidential elections, Montana might look pretty homogenous and conservative. Statewide, Montanans voted overwhelmingly for George W. Bush in 2000 and again in 2004, by margins of 19 and 20 percentage points, respectively, proving themselves to be considerably more enthusiastic about Bush than much of the rest of the country. But those same Montana voters summarily ousted the Republican Party from the governor's office and majority power in both chambers of the state Legislature in 2004. Today, all but one of the major posts in Montana state government are held by Democrats.
One of the first people to step up to the box-office window to see "Brokeback Mountain" when it opened last Friday at the Strand, an old single-screen movie house in Kalispell, was a gray-haired man who would identify himself only as Fishbah.
"What the hell, a couple cowboys? They've got the choice of sheep, cows and cowboys -- which would you choose?" he mused.
The Blue Moon is a sprawling cowboy bar on a rural highway between Whitefish and Columbia Falls. One wall of the barroom is taken up by a glass display case containing two stuffed Kodiak bears and one polar bear, frozen in attack poses. A house band jangles through a series of country hits onstage, while men and women in Stetsons and crisp jeans swing-dance on the wooden dance floor.
Eight men and one woman sat quietly around a poker table. As I sat down, a waitress walked up and placed a single red rose on a chair near the dealer. A man at the far end of the table noticed it and picked it up. A grin flashed across his face, and he handed it to the man next to him.
"This is for you," said the man with the rose.
"Hey, isn't that cute -- it's like that 'Brokeback Mountain,'" interjected another man sitting at the table, who laughed heartily at his own joke. "That shit, what's up with the gay cowboy?" The others at the table grinned and shook their heads.
"Anybody planning to see the movie?" I ventured. One guy glanced up from his cards. Another guy shrugged, not committing either way.
The person who painted this must have the best job ever. Imagine: "We've found this 164 million year old skeleton of a mammal that is a cross between a beaver, otter and platypus. Could you imagine what it would look like swimming and paint us a picture?" Awesome.
